Analysis: How Did Independents Fair in the 2026 Idaho Elections?

Written by

in

Compared to previous election cycles in Idaho, there were a number of races in 2026 where Democrats did not field candidates. Historically, Democrats have attempted to fill nearly every race possible with a candidate.

In several of the races where Democrats did not run, Independent candidates entered the contest instead. Some Republicans alleged that Democrats and their allies were attempting to compete under the Independent label rather than the Democrat banner.

It should also be noted that some races featured no challenger to the Republican candidate at all. In a handful of contests, Constitution Party of Idaho candidates challenged Republican incumbents.

The highest-profile race featuring an Independent candidate was the U.S. Senate contest between Republican Sen. Jim Risch and Independent candidate Todd Achilles.

Achilles previously served as a Democrat lawmaker before launching his Senate campaign as an Independent. Democrat David Roth initially entered the race and won his party’s nomination, but later withdrew. Roth later alleged that party leaders pressured him to leave the contest.

In the end, Achilles received 33.57% of the vote compared to Risch’s 56.50%. Another Independent candidate, Natalie Fleming, was also on the ballot, though she has run as an Independent for several election cycles.

The Senate race was not the only contest where Democrats declined to field a candidate.

In Legislative District 1, Republican Sen. Scott Herndon defeated Independent Steve Johnson by a margin of 57.27% to 42.73%.

In District 1, Seat B, Republican incumbent Cornel Rasor defeated Independent Kathryn Larson 63.95% to 36.05%.

In District 8, Seat A, Republican Rob Beiswenger defeated Independent Heather Lewis 60.80% to 39.20%.

In District 24, Seat A, Independent Kevin Moxley challenged Republican incumbent Clint Hostetler but was defeated 69.5% to 30.5%.

In District 25, Seat B, Republican Cherie Vollmer defeated Independent candidate Liyah Babayan 62.40% to 37.60%.

So, did the strategy of an Independent challenging a Republican, with no Democrat in the race, work?

None of the Independent candidates examined in this article won their races, and Republicans maintained control of each seat. On the surface, the results do not show electoral success for the strategy.

However, supporters of the approach may argue that some candidates performed better than they would have under the Democrat label. Critics contend that the election results suggest the Independent label made little difference.

Whether running as an Independent improved the candidates’ performance is a question voters can decide for themselves.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *